Painful Quandary

Enchantment Rare

Painful Quandary has 8 printings across 6 sets. The cheapest English printing is around £0.96 and the extended art BRO #331 is the most valuable at £3.65. 3 eBay deals were spotted on this card in the last 30 days.

Share: Reddit

Printings & variations (33)

Every set, frame treatment, and language we track — click a printing to view its image and value. All languages (33)

en

FDN #179 £1.24
en

SOM #73 £2.12
en

BRO #111 £0.96
Extended art en

BRO #331 £3.65
en

PBRO #111s
en

PBRO #111p £2.09
en

PFDN #179s
en

PRM #105716

Similar cards

Visually similar artwork from across the catalogue.

Variant summary

100 recorded sales

Raw 100 sales

£1.36

last sold 23 Oct 2026

Median: £1.78
Avg: £2.04
Min: £0.74
Max: £7.96

Condition breakdown (raw sales)

NM 62 LP 12

Market intelligence

raw copies · last 6 months

Liquidity

15.0

raw sales / month

Momentum

▲ +14.0%

last 4w vs prior 4w

ATH proximity

17%

of ATH (£7.96)

PSA 10 multiplier

—

needs ≥3 PSA 10 sales

Grading analysis

vs raw baseline

Raw baseline

£2.11

Median of this printing's recent raw sales · the multiplier baseline

💎 PSA 10 No data

No PSA 10 sales recorded yet — check back once graded copies trade.

Grading fee ~£20

💎 PSA 9 No data

No PSA 9 sales recorded yet — check back once graded copies trade.

Grading fee ~£20

Raw (441) Graded (0)

1M 3M 6M 1Y All

All markets UK US

£3.08 mean asking, last 90 days

1310 asking observations · £0.75–£35.27 range

27 recorded sales · median £2.02 · last sold 23 Oct 2026 · ▲ trending up

Market data updated 3 months, 1 week ago. Sign in to request fresh market data →

Sales history

100 sales

Realised eBay sold prices matched to this card — actual prices paid, not asking prices.

All Raw · NM LP

Sold ▼	Price	Variant	Printing	Cond.	Market	Title
23 Oct 2026	£1.36	Raw	BRO · 111	LP	UK	Painful Quandary - FO MTG - Light Play
22 Oct 2026	£3.52	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	UK	Magic The Gathering Painful Quandary FDN NM
21 Oct 2026	£1.83	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	US	Painful Quandary The Brothers' War 111 NM
21 Oct 2026	£1.97	Raw	SOM · 73	LP	UK	Painful Quandary - Scars of Mirrodin - MTG Magic the Gathering - LP
18 Oct 2026	£2.24	Raw	FDN · 179	—	US	Painful Quandary #0179 Foil Foundations
18 Oct 2026	£2.23	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	UK	Painful Quandary 111 Rare The Brothers' War Magic: The Gathering Near Mint
17 Oct 2026	£1.12	Raw	FDN · 179	—	US	Painful Quandary - 179 - Foundations
16 Oct 2026	£2.24	Raw	FDN · 179	—	US	Painful Quandary 179 Foundations Foil
16 Oct 2026	£4.44	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	US	Painful Quandary - FDN - 179 - Foil - NM - MTG
14 Oct 2026	£2.63	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	US	Painful Quandary - 111 - NM - Promo Pack: The Brothers' War
14 Oct 2026	£7.96	Raw	BRO · 331	LP	UK	Painful Quandary (Extended Art) #331 (Foil) (LP) Brothers' War BRO Magic MTG
12 Oct 2026	£2.26	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	UK	Painful Quandary 179 Rare Foundations Magic: The Gathering Near Mint
10 Oct 2026	£2.44	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	UK	Painful Quandary NonFoil The Brothers' War 111 NM MTG
10 Oct 2026	£1.35	Raw	FDN · 179	LP	US	JP Painful Quandary (Japanese) 179 Foundations Rare LP
8 Oct 2026	£2.26	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	US	Painful Quandary - 111 - NM - The Brothers' War
8 Oct 2026	£3.08	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	UK	Painful Quandary Rare Foundations 179 MTG Near Mint
7 Oct 2026	£2.25	Raw	BRO · 111	—	US	Painful Quandary The Brothers' War Rare Regular 111
7 Oct 2026	£1.66	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	UK	Painful Quandary 111 Rare The Brothers' War Magic: The Gathering Near Mint
6 Oct 2026	£1.86	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	UK	Painful Quandary 179 - R FDN - Magic: The Gathering NM
5 Oct 2026	£1.51	Raw	BRO · 111	LP	US	Painful Quandary 111 Magic The Brothers' War Normal Lightly Played
1 Oct 2026	£1.81	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	UK	Painful Quandary Foundations 179 MTG Magic the Gathering NM
27 Sep 2026	£1.55	Raw	BRO · 111	NM	US	Painful Quandary Normal R The Brothers' War 111 NM
27 Sep 2026	£1.95	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	US	MTG FDN FOIL R Painful Quandary #179 NM
26 Sep 2026	£1.51	Raw	FDN · 179	—	US	Painful Quandary Foundations Regular
24 Sep 2026	£1.45	Raw	FDN · 179	NM	US	Painful Quandary FDN 179 NM Foil

Page 1 of 4 Older →

Marketplace links

Jump straight to the searches collectors actually run. As an eBay Partner and TCGplayer affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Active listings Sold prices Lowest price first Auctions ending soon PSA graded Buy on TCGplayer $1.66

Recent listings

These are eBay asking prices, not confirmed sales. Seller ratings are from eBay at last check — review the seller and listing before buying.

Title	Price	Seller	Marketplace	Seen
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	$4.48	100.0% (142)	eBay United States	18 hours, 38 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	£3.35	100.0% (142)	eBay United Kingdom	18 hours, 38 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	$4.48	100.0% (142)	eBay United States	19 hours, 8 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	£3.35	100.0% (142)	eBay United Kingdom	19 hours, 8 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	$4.48	100.0% (142)	eBay United States	19 hours, 38 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	£3.35	100.0% (142)	eBay United Kingdom	19 hours, 38 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	$4.48	100.0% (142)	eBay United States	20 hours, 8 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	£3.35	100.0% (142)	eBay United Kingdom	20 hours, 8 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	$4.48	100.0% (142)	eBay United States	20 hours, 38 minutes ago	View
Painful quandary-MTG Magic: the gathering-BRO The brothers' war-Painful Dilemma	£3.35	100.0% (142)	eBay United Kingdom	20 hours, 38 minutes ago	View