Recurring Nightmare

Enchantment Rare

Recurring Nightmare has 4 printings across 4 sets. The cheapest English printing is around £10.00 and the retro frame EXO #72 is the most valuable at £61.21. 12 eBay deals were spotted on this card in the last 30 days.

Share: Reddit

Printings & variations (12)

Every set, frame treatment, and language we track — click a printing to view its image and value. All languages (12)

Retro frame en

EXO #72 £61.21
en

TPR #113
en

VMA #137
Retro frame en

WC98 #bs72 £10.00

Similar cards

Visually similar artwork from across the catalogue.

Variant summary

15 recorded sales

Raw 9 sales

£44.30

last sold 22 Oct 2026

Median: £46.49
Avg: £46.33
Min: £8.10
Max: £67.84

PSA 9 1 sale

£71.03

last sold 11 Oct 2026

Median: £71.03
Avg: £71.03
Min: £71.03
Max: £71.03

Condition breakdown (raw sales)

NM 3 LP 1 HP 2

Market intelligence

raw copies · last 6 months

Liquidity

1.5

raw sales / month

Momentum

▲ +31.4%

last 4w vs prior 4w

ATH proximity

65%

of ATH (£67.84)

PSA 10 multiplier

—

needs ≥3 PSA 10 sales

Grading analysis

vs raw baseline

Raw baseline

£46.49

Median of this printing's recent raw sales · the multiplier baseline

💎 PSA 10 No data

No PSA 10 sales recorded yet — check back once graded copies trade.

Grading fee ~£20

💎 PSA 9 Marginal

£71.03

median · 1 sale

1.53×

vs raw

Est. profit after grading (£20 fee)

+£4.54

Grading ROI calculator

interactive · adjust your buy price

Your buy price

PSA 9 1 sale · £20 fee

Expected sale £71.03

Profit

—

ROI

—

Defaults to the raw median. Grading fees are estimates — postage and turnaround vary by service level.

Raw (179) Graded (27)

1M 3M 6M 1Y All

All markets UK US

£67.52 mean asking, last 90 days

391 asking observations · £1.49–£298.33 range

9 recorded sales · median £46.49 · last sold 22 Oct 2026 · ▼ trending down

No sold-price data fetched for this card yet. Sign in to request fresh market data →

Sales history

15 sales

Realised eBay sold prices matched to this card — actual prices paid, not asking prices.

All Raw PSA 9 · NM LP HP

Sold ▼	Price	Variant	Printing	Cond.	Market	Title
22 Oct 2026	£44.30	Raw	EXO · 72	HP	US	Recurring Nightmare - Heavy Play MTG Exodus
20 Oct 2026	£59.94	Raw	EXO · 72	NM	US	Recurring Nightmare X1 Mtg Exodus Nm/Nm- (3 Available)
18 Oct 2026	£49.52	psa8	EXO · 72	—	UK	1998 MTG EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 8
17 Oct 2026	£46.49	Raw	EXO · 72	NM	US	MTG RECURRING NIGHTMARE NM Exodus Magic: the Gathering
17 Oct 2026	£8.10	Raw	EXO · 72	—	UK	Recurring Nightmare X1 Mtg World Championships
15 Oct 2026	£43.20	Raw	EXO · 72	—	UK	Magic The Gathering Exodus Recurring Nightmare
11 Oct 2026	£71.03	PSA 9	EXO · 72	—	UK	1998 MAGIC THE GATHERING EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 9
6 Oct 2026	£68.07	psa8	EXO · 72	—	UK	1998 MTG EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 8
4 Oct 2026	£33.23	psa8	EXO · 72	—	UK	1998 MAGIC: THE GATHERING EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 8
3 Oct 2026	£32.57	cgc5.5	EXO · 72	—	UK	Magic: The Gathering Recurring Nightmare 1998 Exodus 72/143 Rare CGC 5.5
1 Oct 2026	£67.84	Raw	EXO · 72	LP	UK	MTG Recurring Nightmare Exodus Reserved List LP Rare
29 Sep 2026	£61.86	Raw	EXO · 72	—	UK	MTG Recurring Nightmare - Signed - Exodus Magic the Gathering Card #72
27 Sep 2026	£49.07	Raw	EXO · 72	NM	UK	MTG English Recurring Nightmare NM Normal Exodus
27 Sep 2026	£40.01	psa8	EXO · 72	—	UK	1998 MAGIC: THE GATHERING EXODUS #72 RECURRING NIGHTMARE PSA 8
26 Sep 2026	£36.21	Raw	EXO · 72	HP	US	1x Recurring Nightmare Heavy Play MTG Magic - Kid Icarus -

Marketplace links

Jump straight to the searches collectors actually run. As an eBay Partner and TCGplayer affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Active listings Sold prices Lowest price first Auctions ending soon PSA graded Buy on TCGplayer $81.83

Recent listings

These are eBay asking prices, not confirmed sales. Seller ratings are from eBay at last check — review the seller and listing before buying.

Title	Price	Seller	Marketplace	Seen
MTG Playmat Recurring Nightmare Signed	$196.39	100.0% (700)	eBay United States	9 hours, 51 minutes ago	View
MTG Recurring Nightmare - Signed - Exodus Magic the Gathering Card #72	£56.08	99.9% (2112)	eBay United Kingdom	1 day ago	View
MTG Recurring Nightmare - Signed - Exodus Magic the Gathering Card #72	$75.00	99.9% (2112)	eBay United States	1 day ago	View
Recurring Nightmare Exodus NM (Reserved List MTG Magic Card) (529638) ABUGames	$93.05	99.7% (156712)	eBay United States	2 days, 5 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare Exodus NM (Reserved List MTG Magic Card) (529638) ABUGames	£83.32	99.7% (156712)	eBay United Kingdom	2 days, 5 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare - 1998 Brian Selden (EXO) - Light Play MTG	$18.62	99.8% (17152)	eBay United States	3 days, 18 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare - 1998 Brian Selden (EXO) - Light Play MTG	£16.70	99.8% (17152)	eBay United Kingdom	3 days, 18 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare - 1998 Brian Selden (EXO) - Light Play MTG	$18.62	99.8% (17152)	eBay United States	3 days, 18 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare - 1998 Brian Selden (EXO) - Light Play MTG	£16.70	99.8% (17152)	eBay United Kingdom	3 days, 18 hours ago	View
Recurring Nightmare X1 Mtg Exodus Lp	$75.00	99.8% (2731)	eBay United States	3 days, 19 hours ago	View