Ad As an eBay Partner and TCGplayer affiliate, Cardboard Deals earns from qualifying purchases. eBay and TCGplayer links on this site are affiliate links. Learn more
Cardboard Deals
Magic: The Gathering

Switch game

All games

Thalia, Heretic Cathar

Legendary Creature — Human Soldier Rare

Thalia, Heretic Cathar has 10 printings across 7 sets. The cheapest English printing is around £0.72 and the borderless SLD #1428 is the most valuable at £4.89. 1 eBay deal was spotted on this card in the last 30 days.

Share: Reddit

Printings & variations (20)

Every set, frame treatment, and language we track — click a printing to view its image and value. All languages (20)

Similar cards

Visually similar artwork from across the catalogue.

Variant summary

41 recorded sales
Raw 39 sales
£2.08
last sold 25 Oct 2026
Median
£2.26
Avg
£3.45
Min
£1.11
Max
£12.23
PSA 10 1 sale
£26.22
last sold 19 Oct 2026
Median
£26.22
Avg
£26.22
Min
£26.22
Max
£26.22
PSA 9 1 sale
£18.72
last sold 19 Oct 2026
Median
£18.72
Avg
£18.72
Min
£18.72
Max
£18.72
Condition breakdown (raw sales)
NM 23 LP 3 MP 2

Market intelligence

raw copies · last 6 months
Liquidity
6.5
raw sales / month
Momentum
▲ +45.9%
last 4w vs prior 4w
ATH proximity
17%
of ATH (£12.23)
PSA 10 multiplier
—
needs ≥3 PSA 10 sales

Grading analysis

vs raw baseline
Raw baseline
£2.33
Median of recent raw sales across all printings (too few for this one) · the multiplier baseline
💎 PSA 10 Strong
£26.22
median · 1 sale
11.25×
vs raw
Est. profit after grading (£20 fee)
+£3.89
💎 PSA 9 Strong
£18.72
median · 1 sale
8.03×
vs raw
Est. profit after grading (£20 fee)
£-3.61

Grading ROI calculator

interactive · adjust your buy price
£
PSA 10 1 sale · £20 fee
Expected sale £26.22
Profit
—
ROI
—
PSA 9 1 sale · £20 fee
Expected sale £18.72
Profit
—
ROI
—

Defaults to the raw median. Grading fees are estimates — postage and turnaround vary by service level.

Raw (294) Graded (216)
1M 3M 6M 1Y All
All markets UK US
£3.83 mean asking, last 90 days

594 asking observations · £0.75–£73.20 range

39 recorded sales · median £2.26 · last sold 25 Oct 2026 · ▲ trending up

No sold-price data fetched for this card yet. Sign in to request fresh market data →

Sales history

41 sales

Realised eBay sold prices matched to this card — actual prices paid, not asking prices.

All Raw PSA 10 PSA 9 · NM LP MP
Sold ▼ Price Title
25 Oct 2026 £2.08 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Eldritch Moon NM MTG
19 Oct 2026 £18.72 2025 MTG INNISTRAD REMASTERED RETRO FRAME-FOIL #351 THALIA, HERETIC CATHAR PSA 9
19 Oct 2026 £26.22 2025 MTG INNISTRAD REMASTERED BORDERLESS-FOIL THALIA, HERETIC CATHAR PSA 10
16 Oct 2026 £2.25 Thalia Heretic Cathar 46 Eldritch Moon MTG NM
15 Oct 2026 £2.09 Thalia, Heretic Cathar (Borderless) - INR - LP [Foil] TCG MTG
15 Oct 2026 £4.87 Thalia, Heretic Cathar - PRE - LP [Foil] TCG MTG
15 Oct 2026 £6.76 MTG Thalia, Heretic Cathar Borderless ** Secret Lair Drop ** English
15 Oct 2026 £3.18 Thalia, Heretic Cathar 46 Promo Buy-A-Box Promos Magic: The Gathering Foil NM
15 Oct 2026 £9.46 Thalia, Heretic Cathar (Rainbow Foil) 1428 -MTG Secret Lair Drop English NM-Mint
12 Oct 2026 £2.86 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Innistrad Remastered Magic: The Gathering Foil NM
12 Oct 2026 £12.23 Thalia, Heretic Cathar #2016 *Foil* (NM) Secret Lair Countdown Kit (SLC) MTG
11 Oct 2026 £3.99 Thalia, Heretic Cathar ~ Innistrad Remastered [ NM ] [ Magic MTG ]
11 Oct 2026 £2.92 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Foil Innistrad Remastered 300 NM MTG
8 Oct 2026 £1.81 Thalia, Heretic Cathar (Retro Frame) Innistrad Remastered
8 Oct 2026 £2.22 Thalia, Heretic Cathar (Borderless) Innistrad Remastered Magic: The Gathering NM
5 Oct 2026 £1.94 THALIA, HERETIC CATHAR NM! *ELDRITCH MOON*
4 Oct 2026 £2.64 Thalia, Heretic Cathar 46 Promo Buy-A-Box Promos Magic: The Gathering Foil NM
4 Oct 2026 £2.40 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Foil Innistrad Remastered 44 NM MTG
4 Oct 2026 £1.84 Thalia, Heretic Cathar (Borderless) Innistrad Remastered Magic: The Gathering NM
3 Oct 2026 £3.98 FOIL Thalia, Heretic Cathar ~ Buy a Box Eldritch Moon [ EX ] [ Magic MTG ]
3 Oct 2026 £8.00 MTG - Thalia, Heretic Cathar - Showcase - Free P+P
2 Oct 2026 £4.17 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Secret Lair NM MTG
2 Oct 2026 £5.73 MTG Thalia, Heretic Cathar [SLC] #2016 en
30 Sep 2026 £4.52 Thalia, Heretic Cathar Secret Lair Countdown Kit Regular
29 Sep 2026 £1.32 2025 Magic: The Gathering INR Thalia, Heretic Cathar 44
Page 1 of 2 Older →

Marketplace links

Jump straight to the searches collectors actually run. As an eBay Partner and TCGplayer affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Active listings Sold prices Lowest price first Auctions ending soon PSA graded Buy on TCGplayer

Recent listings

These are eBay asking prices, not confirmed sales. Seller ratings are from eBay at last check — review the seller and listing before buying.

Title Price Seller Seen
MTG Magic Thalia, Heretic Cathar Secret Lair 1428 (Rainbow Foil) NM Never Played $17.50 100.0% 9 hours, 22 minutes ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar Non-Foil 1428 - MTG Secret Lair Drop NM-Mint Never Played $11.99 100.0% 9 hours, 22 minutes ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar Non-Foil 1428 - MTG Secret Lair Drop NM-Mint Never Played £10.76 100.0% 9 hours, 23 minutes ago View
MTG Magic Thalia, Heretic Cathar Secret Lair 1428 (Rainbow Foil) NM Never Played £15.70 100.0% 9 hours, 23 minutes ago View
MTG Thalia, Heretic Cathar (46/79) Eldritch Moon Promos LP FOIL- Prerelease $4.95 99.8% 1 day, 12 hours ago View
MTG Thalia, Heretic Cathar (46/79) Eldritch Moon Promos LP FOIL- Prerelease £4.44 99.8% 1 day, 12 hours ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar - PEMN - 46 - Foil - NM - MTG $5.26 99.9% 3 days, 8 hours ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar - PEMN - 46 - Foil - NM - MTG £3.93 99.9% 3 days, 8 hours ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar - PEMN - 46 - Foil - NM - MTG $2.95 99.9% 3 days, 8 hours ago View
Thalia, Heretic Cathar - PEMN - 46 - Foil - NM - MTG £2.20 99.9% 3 days, 8 hours ago View